5 Best TV Shows Like Peacock's Crystal Lake
Peacock's "Crystal Lake" takes us back in time to see the lives of Jason and Pamela Voorhees, the core characters of the "Friday the 13th" franchise. The movies feature Jason in his adult form, but the show presents his childhood and the formative experience of going to summer camp. However, not every kid has his mother tagging along as the camp's cook. What follows is a look into the bullying of Jason by other campers and how Pamela reacts to the harsh treatment of her son.
"Crystal Lake" does an excellent job of combining the slasher elements of the films, the summer camp setting, and the nature of an upset mother on a mission into a strong prequel. If you want to dive into similar series, there are so many great options. Was it being a prequel your favorite part? There are other shows featuring the origin stories of fan-favorite horror villains. Are you a campy slasher enthusiast? There are projects for that too. No matter which facet of "Crystal Lake" stood out to you, these are the best shows to watch next.
American Horror Story: 1984
"American Horror Story" is a stellar option for horror enthusiasts, but the ninth season in particular, called "1984," is perfect for fans of "Crystal Lake." Led by Emma Roberts as Brooke Thompson, the season follows counselors helping with a lakeside summer camp in the 1980s. It previously closed a decade prior due to murders, but the time has come to reopen. After a serial killer goes after Brooke in Los Angeles, she decides the best way to hide is to go off the grid at this camp for a few weeks.
Previous seasons of "American Horror Story" were influenced by the found footage genre, haunted house movies, and popular paranormal characters like witches and scary clowns, and this season is no different. The influence from "Friday the 13th" couldn't be more obvious, and for that alone it's worth the watch if you like the prequel series. It's the ideal thing to follow up "Crystal Lake" with if you want to binge another spooky summer camp slasher.
"1984" comes a bit later in the "American Horror Story" lineup, but it's the highest rated season, earning an 88% from critics on Rotten Tomatoes. Like other Ryan Murphy projects, there is some concern with the portrayal of a real serial killer, in this case Richard Ramirez, but if you're watching for the campy slasher elements, you won't be disappointed.
Bates Motel
"Bates Motel" takes us back in time to when Norman Bates' (Freddie Highmore) mother Norma (Vera Farmiga) is alive and not a preserved corpse in a seedy roadside motel. Instead, the series shows us what life was like after they purchased the motel and Norman's mental health shifts, resulting in a more controlling Norma, representative of the "Mother" alternate personality observed in "Psycho."
While "Friday the 13th" is about Jason Voorhees and his antics, the franchise is more so about a relationship with a mother, like Pamela in "Crystal Lake." Since they're both prequel projects, they give a better insight into the mother-son relationship of their parent franchises. Norman and Jason are both outcasts, struggling to fit in with those around them, causing them to rely heavily on their mothers. Pamela's actions are rooted in that bond, and that's a core part of Norma's story as well.
"Bates Motel" boasts a 93% from critics and a 91% from audiences across its five seasons on Rotten Tomatoes. Highmore and Farmiga received multiple nominations for their performances in the series, including an Emmy nomination for the latter and Critics Choice awards nominations for both.
Harper's Island
In the summer of 2009, CBS released "Harper's Island," a miniseries following a wedding weekend on the titular island. Several years before, there was an active serial killer on the island, and it seems someone may be imitating them when wedding guests start disappearing. In addition to getting married, the happy couple and their loved ones have to figure out who the killer is and try to end their string of attacks.
While Camp Crystal Lake isn't necessarily as isolated as Harper's Island, the thicket of trees surrounding the camp certainly makes it feel that way. It's out in the middle of the woods, with no easy way out. "Harper's Island" has a bit more of a mystery feel, since you're trying to work out who the killer is alongside the characters, but there's clear inspiration from slashers, particularly with the killer's creativity.
Though "Harper's Island" has a 65% from critics on Rotten Tomatoes, it garnered more love since its release. At the time, it was meant to become an anthology, predating "American Horror Story" by two years. While that didn't pan out, retrospective takes acknowledge that it should've become an anthology series and that social media trends, like live-tweeting, would've made a difference in its ratings. It just came out a bit too early.
IT: Welcome to Derry
What was happening in Derry before the events of "It"? "Welcome to Derry" explores just that. Bill Skarsgård returns as Pennywise, taking us back to the 1960s to show what Stephen King's most frightening character was up to then. He antagonizes families as kids go missing, exactly what you would expect, but the series has more room to explore the entity behind Pennywise and what makes him tick.
Both are prequels to staple horror franchises and do fantastic jobs of capturing the vibes that made their respective franchises popular. "Crystal Lake" embodies the campy slasher nature of "Friday the 13th" well, while "Welcome to Derry" focuses on the darkness that stands out in "It." They aren't quite character studies, but they give important insight into their main characters, further building out their fictional universes.
With an 81% from critics on Rotten Tomatoes, "Welcome to Derry" does a wonderful job of expanding King's original story while including sociocultural commentary. USA Today's Kelly Lawler writes that the series "packs its scares with some thoughtful meditations about race and Americana," while Aramide Tinubu called it "a masterfully woven and terrifying tale" for Variety.
Swamp Thing
"Swamp Thing" follows Abby Arcane (Crystal Reed), a doctor looking into something plaguing her Louisiana hometown. She's instead greeted by another scientist who may be conducting experiments in the depths of the swamps under the guise of contaminant clean up, resulting in the titular creature. There's something off about the plant life, attacking people and being way more sentient than it should be.
While this may seem like an odd recommendation, "Swamp Thing" is a great watch for people who love the setting of "Crystal Lake." It isn't a summer camp, it's a swampy forest, and it has the same eerie feeling of the woods surrounding the camp. The creepy lake is swapped out for the standing water of the swamp. Though the series leans more into science than slasher, it really captures how scary the water can be, since you never know who or what is lurking beneath the surface.
"Swamp Thing" is an underrated show, especially considering the 92% critics scores on Rotten Tomatoes. It only got one season, cancelled due to business decisions and not because of its performance or ratings, but that shouldn't stop you from checking it out.