Paul Rudd's Forgotten Sci-Fi Comedy Series Is An Underrated Netflix Gem

Add BGR on Google:
Google Discover

Throughout his three-decade-plus acting career, Paul Rudd has been a lot of things: a best friend, Marvel superhero, Sexiest Man Alive (in his 50s!), and so on. You know his face as well as the logos of the biggest sports brands. He's smooth, amiable, and effortlessly funny. Yet he's often doing his best work when he's playing an unexpected version of that persona he carefully built over the years. A smarmy, sneaky psychiatrist in "The Shrink Next Door," a low-achieving musician in "Power Ballad," or two opposing versions of the same person in Netflix's 2019 miniseries, "Living With Yourself."

Many have forgotten about Timothy Greenberg's eight-episode sci-fi dramedy, even though it was a low-key gem at the time of its release. It's practically a darker, deeper, more existential version of Michael Keaton's post-Batman comedy "Multiplicity," exploring the idea of cloning in a slightly different fashion. The plot follows Miles Elliott (Rudd), a resigned and depressed copywriter, who's just as burnt out at his job as he is in his marriage.

He and his wife Kate (Aisling Bea) try to conceive and start a family, but given Miles's half-hearted effort, it's not going well. So when he gets a tip from his co-worker, who's been crushing life lately, to visit a mysterious spa where they can make him better in every possible way, he doesn't hesitate to give it a go. Sacrificing all their savings, Miles goes for the procedure, then wakes up in a grave, finding out the better version of him is actually a clone — and now he'll have to compete with him to keep his own wife.

Living With Yourself was a short-lived hit

Despite pleasing the majority of critics (the series has a 79% rating on Rotten Tomatoes as of this writing), "Living With Yourself" wasn't exactly a smash hit for the ages. As much as its writing is clever and handsomely entertaining, along with a solid mix of Rudd being equally hilarious and dramatic in the lead role, it just wasn't that kind of show. Still, as a huge fan of the criminally underrated "Multiplicity," I think Greenberg's series deserved more in the long run — even a potential continuation that would've been possible, considering the note the first season ended on.

That's not to say "Living With Yourself" couldn't have gone deeper to explore its central themes like identity, the fake side of self-help culture, and marital struggles further with a braver, sort of "swing for the fences" approach. But considering that its core concept was all about mining absurd and dark comedy, it's an accomplishment that Greenberg and Co. actually added layers to it that genuinely provided food for thought beyond playing the typical clichés of the familiar "clone narrative."

With a top-tier and perfectly picked supporting cast that included such talents as Zach Cherry, Desmin Borges, Alia Shawkat, Karen Pittman, Rob Yang, and Jon Glaser, no less — in addition to Rudd's double-act and Bea's surprisingly nuanced turn as the love interest. If you're a fan of Rudd and black comedy spiced with a sci-fi gimmick, and somehow missed this one back in the day, you should definitely add it to your watchlist and dive in as soon as you find the time. It's a treat.

Recommended