3 YouTube Problems I Hope Google Fixes Soon
I love YouTube. I've been a YouTube Premium subscriber since April 2019 — a year after it was renamed from YouTube Red — and I recall when the first YouTube Rewind featuring its creators aired in 2012. I've stuck with Premium through price increase after increase. I use it to learn, to be entertained, to play background music while I work, for motivation at the gym ... the list goes on. It's the most used app on my phone by no small margin. However, it also has problems that Google desperately needs to address to save its user experience.
YouTube has changed a lot over the years, going from unedited videos filmed on an old family camcorder to the current MrBeast-ified state of production quality and inevitable ad reads. One YouTube feature has evolved right along with these changes: the algorithm. In the past, you could subscribe to a few creators you happened upon through word of mouth or a collaboration (often called a "collab") with a channel you already followed, and these channels made up the bulk of your homepage. Now, YouTube believes it knows you better than you know yourself, cramming recommendations down your throat from channels you've never seen before.
Algorithm aside, AI slop and advertisements have infected the social media giant. You don't have to look far to see something that had little to no human involvement in its creation. And then there's the problem of YouTube's search function — when did it get so unreliable? Nowadays, looking for a specific video gives you a handful of on-topic recommendations, then shoves you right back into recommendations it thinks has the best chance of keeping you on the platform longer.
Please, Google: It's time to fix the YouTube algorithm
Scrolling through my homepage, I estimate that YouTube's recommendations outnumber recent videos from channels I've subscribed to by about three to one. The rest of the page is flooded with topics I watched one or two videos about (short clips in particular are repeat offenders), YouTube Shorts enticing me to scroll, and features like YouTube Playables that have nothing to do with my subscriptions.
The Subscriptions page does still exist, but it's not the main focus of the site on desktop, and, on mobile, it's been moved to a tiny tab. And even then, clicking on the Subscriptions tab gives you a few of the latest videos, then gets sorted by "Most Relevant" before returning to chronological order. The modern YouTube algorithm has been engineered like a labyrinth, weaving you through traps and trials before finally rewarding you with the video you came for. Google, I want the old algorithm back. Let me choose what I see; don't hold my homepage captive.
It's important to note that we do actually have some power over the YouTube algorithm — clicking on the three dots at the bottom right of a recommendation and clicking "Not Interested" or "Don't recommend channel" does affect what you see. You can also go through your YouTube history to delete topics you're not interested in watching, shaping what the algorithm draws from. I haven't had as much luck using this tactic with Shorts, however. YouTube seems to reduce Shorts recommendations for a day or two, then goes right back to putting them front and center on the homepage. I do appreciate the built-in time management feature for Shorts, which I have set to 15 minutes per day.
YouTube's AI slop takeover and its unreliable search bar
With the rapid rise of artificial intelligence has come nefarious actors preying on unsuspecting viewers through low-effort AI advertisements. Several large YouTube personalities and analysts like GEN and Pleasant Green have posted videos such as "WTF Is Happening To YouTube?" and "AI Ads Are Out of Control" discussing this topic. They question how Google can continue to allow blatant AI scam ads before videos and highlight its absurdity. Google desperately needs to do a better job of vetting advertisements and preventing scammers from using AI-generated ads to steal money from its viewers.
AI slop aside, YouTube's search function has been steadily declining for some time now. Before, you could search for a topic or specific video and either find it right away or see a list of closely related results. Now, searching a specific term sees you sifting through Shorts, inline ads, and a host of recommendations YouTube thinks you'd like to see. You can use the built-in filters to help, which I suggest if you don't want to get pulled into an hour-long session of doomscrolling through unrelated Shorts.