The Reason Why I Keep Paying For AppleCare+ On My iPhone
Apple's first foldable has a lot of people thinking about phone insurance again. Within days of the iPhone Duo going on sale, some owners started reporting that their device's inner display had cracked on its own, and Apple told everyone affected to contact AppleCare for a replacement. That's not what you want when you've just spent $1,999 on a new phone. And while Apple's replacement for this defect doesn't require AppleCare+, the situation could be even worse if you crack the display yourself and skipped past the option to add AppleCare+ to your device.
I've had AppleCare coverage on every iPhone I've carried since my iPhone 17 Pro Max, then my iPhone 18 Pro Max, and now the iPhone Duo, which I use daily. These days, I've switched to AppleCare One, which covers my iPhone Duo, my MacBook Pro, and my Apple Watch Ultra 3 under one plan. Nobody enjoys paying for insurance on something they've already handed over a lot of money for, but it's a subscription I don't think twice about.
Why I pay for AppleCare+
While I'm sure this will cause a stir, I have always used my iPhones with no case and no screen protector. I know how that sounds, but it's never steered me wrong. I've had the iPhone 18 Pro and 18 Pro Max since launch, and neither has picked up any scratches or marks, though my 17 Pro Max collected a few dings on the frame over the year I carried it in my pocket. But I've never cracked a display or broken the back panel, touch wood. That's luck as much as anything, and having AppleCare+ has always let me feel confident in this decision.
The repair prices make it clear to see why AppleCare+ is worthwhile. Apple's published service estimates price an inner display repair on the iPhone Duo at $999 without coverage, but that drops to just $99 if you have AppleCare+. Other accidental damage runs as high as $1,499 without a plan and $99 with one. Even if you only drop your iPhone once, the amount you save to get the damage fixed would cover several years of AppleCare+. The math still makes sense even on cheaper iPhones, where repairs can still cost hundreds.
Theft and loss coverage is another excellent perk for anyone who travels a lot, like me. AppleCare+ with Theft and Loss covers up to two claims in a 12-month period, while AppleCare One allows up to three claims a year across all covered devices. I travel through multiple airports most months, and an iPhone is far more likely to vanish in a security tray, a taxi, or a crowded train station than it is to shatter on the pavement after being dropped.
Why you should consider AppleCare+ as well
I think most iPhone owners should consider AppleCare+, especially those with the iPhone Duo. Apple has acknowledged an issue affecting the inner display on a small number of units, where the screen cracks along the hinge line and a band of pixels gets stuck glowing white. Mine has been fine, and some of the problems early Duo owners have run into, have only affected a small share of Duo owners. But foldables are more fragile than slab phones either way. The inner panel has to be soft enough to bend, and the hinge adds moving parts. Plus, as I covered in my iPhone Duo review, the nano-texture layer above the inner display can be swapped for $19 with AppleCare+.
If you own several Apple products, make sure you check out AppleCare One before you start paying for multiple single-device plans. The subscription costs $19.99 a month and lets you cover up to three eligible products, with the ability to add extras for $5.99 a month each. AppleCare+ with Theft and Loss on the iPhone Duo costs $19.99 a month on its own, so it would be silly not to upgrade to AppleCare One and cover more devices for the same cost.
That being said, AppleCare coverage won't pay off for everyone. If you only have an iPhone, keep it in a case, and have never broken a screen in your life, then you may pay for the coverage plan for years and never make a claim. Still, AppleCare brings down repair costs significantly. If you use your iPhone caseless, travel often, or carry one of the most powerful foldables you can buy right now, I strongly advise you get AppleCare+.