5 Smartwatches To Buy Instead Of A New Pixel Watch

Add BGR on Google:
Google Discover

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

By mid-August, Google released its Pixel Watch 5, a new iteration of its smartwatch with a stronger focus on Gemini Intelligence and health features, giving users more insights into their day, lifestyle, and more. Built with repairability in mind, a fast-charging battery, and enhanced fitness tools thanks to Google Health Coach, the new Pixel Watch may not be your cup of tea. You'd rather have something else because you don't use an Android phone, you want something more focused on your running habits, you don't like the watch's shape, or so on. If so, you might be better off with Apple's latest Apple Watch Series 12, the new Samsung Galaxy Watch 9, or even Garmin's new model, the Enduro 4.

BGR selected these smartwatches based on reviews from our staff, as well as praise from specialized media and customers. We chose a wide range of gadgets, from direct competitors to devices that offer something more tailored to the experience you expect, whether it's long-lasting battery life, a specific model for running, or a more rugged option. Whatever your reason for not buying a Google Pixel Watch 5, we have selected five smartwatches that may suit you better than Google's latest Pixel Watch. 

Apple Watch Series 12

The Apple Watch Series 12 can be compared to the Google Pixel Watch 5. However, a lot separates them—especially that the Apple Watch runs exclusively on the iPhone, while the Pixel Watch 5 works best with Android and Pixel phones. Released a month after the Pixel Watch, the new Apple Watch features Apple's dual-core S11 chip with a 4-core Neural Engine and 64GB of storage. Apple promises 24 hours of battery life, which can stretch to 38 hours in Low Power mode. The Series 12 packs an all-new Health Sensing System, which uses a third-generation electrical heart sensor, an optical sensor that checks your pulse every five seconds, blood oxygen and skin temperature tracking, and a water temperature sensor. On top of that, Apple has been testing on-device Audio Intelligence features like Live Rewind and Siri Recap.

Compared to the Google Pixel Watch 5, the biggest deciding factor is simply what phone you have in your pocket, since each smartwatch is locked to its operating system—iOS or Android. Still, even if we ignore phone compatibility, the Apple Watch Series 12 offers a few extra perks, including precision ultra-wideband car unlocking, seamless GymKit equipment pairing, and built-in depth and water temperature sensors that give it a real advantage over Google's offering. BGR also has a complete review of the Apple Watch Series 12, going in depth on why this has been such a good release by Apple. The Series 12 starts at $399, but Amazon currently has it starting at $329.

Samsung Galaxy Watch 9

Released around the same time as the Google Pixel Watch 5, Samsung's Galaxy Watch 9 runs Wear OS 7 with a One UI 9 Watch layer, powered by a 3nm penta-core Qualcomm Snapdragon Wear Elite processor, 2GB of RAM, and 32GB of storage. With around 30 hours of battery life with the always-on display turned on, Samsung's new watch features a BioActive sensor, dual-frequency GPS, a barometer, and skin temperature tracking that brings ECG, blood pressure monitoring, and even an Antioxidant Index. It also bets on an AI health coach, smart sleep reports — although it can do a lot more than that –and a bright 3,000-nit screen with tough sapphire crystal.

Compared to the Google Pixel Watch 5, Samsung brings a new processor to the table, while Google is still stuck with an older architecture that isn't as powerful as Qualcomm's latest chip. Durability is another big differentiator: the Galaxy Watch 9 features a sapphire crystal display, while Google uses Corning Gorilla Glass 5, which can be much easier to scuff over time. Another important point is that if you have a Samsung smartphone, the Galaxy Watch 9 might make more sense, since it offers features like on-demand blood pressure readings and ECG at no extra cost, while Google locks some deeper health insights behind a paid Google Health Premium subscription. The Samsung Galaxy Watch 9 starts at $369.99 on Amazon.

Garmin Enduro 4

Released in October 2026, the Garmin Enduro 4 is one of Garmin's latest watches. If you value endurance over flashy smartwatch tricks, this device runs on an upgraded processor with 50% more RAM than the previous model and offers 64GB of storage for maps and music. Instead of a power-hungry screen, it uses a 1.4-inch transflective MIP display topped with a Power Sapphire solar lens that can deliver up to 36 days of battery life in smartwatch mode, or up to 90 days with plenty of sun. Garmin also promises up to 320 hours in solar-assisted GPS mode. Its sensors also include multi-band GNSS with SatIQ, a barometric altimeter, Pulse Ox, ECG, a compass, and a thermometer. Garmin offers a built-in LED flashlight, offline topographic maps, and, of course, built-in speakers and microphones.

When we compare the Google Pixel Watch 5 with Garmin's Enduro 4, we're talking about completely different philosophies. After all, while the Pixel Watch has a gorgeous AMOLED screen and thousands of Wear OS apps, the Garmin option offers ridiculously long battery life and is perfect for ultrarunners, thru-hikers, or anyone who enjoys multi-day camping trips. With its rugged 10 ATM titanium casing, solar charging and physical buttons that actually work when your fingers are freezing or wet, the latest Garmin watch was built to survive adventures where the Pixel Watch would just give up. BGR also has a more comprehensive list of Garmin alternatives for those who don't want an expensive sports watch. Garmin's Enduro 4 costs $899 at Amazon.

Google Fitbit Edge

In addition to the Google Pixel Watch 5, Google also recently released the Fitbit Edge, a clever middle ground between a slim fitness band and a full smartwatch, which BGR already reviewed. The Fitbit Edge runs on an ultra-efficient Ambiq AP5 microcontroller with 64MB of flash memory and FitbitOS. Since it's so power-efficient, Google promises up to seven days on a single charge, or two days if you keep the 1.34-inch AMOLED screen always on. Despite its small form factor, it features optical heart rate tracking, multipurpose electrical ECG, SpO2, skin temperature, an altimeter, and a GPS. It also includes an industry-first user-replaceable battery, heart rate broadcasting to gym machines, Cardio Load tracking, and Gemini-powered Google Health coaching.

While we are talking about the same company, the main differences between the Pixel Watch 5 and the new Fitbit Edge come down to comfort, battery, and price. The Pixel Watch 5 weighs two Fitbit Edge models, and it needs to be charged every other day, not every week. The Fitbit Edge may be a better option if you don't want a bulky watch on your wrist and want to save money with a $179.99 price tag on Amazon. In addition, the Fitbit Edge also works with both Android and iOS, making it a perfect solution not only for one kind of smartphone user, but any of them. Finally, being able to swap out the battery after a few years makes this device even more enticing.

Apple Watch Ultra 4

From a very slim choice to a rugged one, the Apple Watch Ultra 4 is Apple's toughest wearable. It has the same internals as the Apple Watch Series 12, including the new chip, but it packs a 49mm titanium case, a flat 3,000-nit sapphire crystal display, and battery life that lasts up to 50 hours in normal use and 84 hours in Low Power mode. Still, this watch also offers a customizable Action Button and an 86-decibel emergency siren, and it shares 5G RedCap connectivity and Audio Intelligence features with the Series 12 model — we also have a more in-depth comparison between the Apple Watch Ultra 4 and the Series 12 version.

That said, when we compare the Apple Watch Ultra 4 with the Google Pixel Watch 5, it's easy to see how much more rugged Apple's flagship is. Google prefers a more delicate curved glass that is great for everyday wear, while the Ultra 4 meets MIL-STD-810H military standards, offers 100-meter water resistance and features a raised titanium bezel that protects its flat sapphire screen. Aside from the obvious iPhone compatibility, you should get the Apple Watch Ultra 4 over the Pixel Watch 5 if you enjoy outdoor life, scuba diving, or if you are a marathon runner who needs multi-day battery life, tactile buttons you can press with gloves on, and a built-in dive computer, which is another big perk of this model. The Apple Watch Ultra 4 costs $774 on Amazon.

Methodology

BGR selected these smartwatches because they offer features not available on the Google Pixel Watch 5 and may better resonate with specific users. While BGR reviewed some of the options mentioned above, we also have ongoing experience with these brands, meaning they're no stranger to us. In addition, specialized media and real-life customers have praised these models. We don't mean to say customers shouldn't get the Google Pixel Watch 5, but we wanted to offer a wider range of options—including a completely different operating system with the iPhone and Apple Watch.

Each watch mentioned above has something that might make you choose it. For the Apple Watch Series 12, we're talking about an all-round model for iPhone users; the Galaxy Watch 9 has a newer, more capable processor, the Fitbit Edge features a better battery life and smart features at a cheaper price point, the Garmin Enduro 4 is perfect for outdoorsy people, while the Apple Watch Ultra 4 is Apple's best rugged option with a massive display and premium finish.

That said, these smartwatches beat the Google Pixel Watch 5 in specific areas that might matter depending on how you use a smartwatch— whether you want something simpler, bulkier, more focused on an outdoor lifestyle, or something you'll wear and forget you put on.

Recommended